BAD WEATHER DECISIONS

I thought I’d share a little about how and why “bad weather” decisions are made to close or delay schools. I’d like to begin with one obvious point: Superintendents are no more capable of predicting weather than the weather “experts” we all listen to. (Truly, I wish we had foresight that matched the 20/20 hindsight of a few Facebook aficionados.)

Though my staff and I consult the National Weather Service, local TV weather reports, city officials, our own bus transportation people, other school districts in the area, and multiple sources depending on the circumstance, we remain captive to uncertainties.

In January 2014, we closed schools on two different days under two different circumstances. In the first instance, there was insufficient information the night before for a solid decision. Some local districts decided to institute a 2-hour delay for the next morning. As it turned out, this did not work out for them. Accidents occurred. A few districts (primarily to the east and south of us) closed schools the night before, believing that the weather pattern put their districts in the epicenter of the predicted ice. Their decision turned out to be a good one. But Pearland was not in that epicenter; thus, the decision was more difficult.

Since the necessity for closing schools remained very uncertain the night before, our transportation director began driving the roads at 3 a.m. on the day in question. He called me at 4:15 a.m. and essentially told me that the roads were not iced over but that it was difficult to predict whether that situation would change in the next few hours. The weather north of us was worse and the storm was moving east rather than south. I asked him to call me back in 30 minutes after I had re-examined weather updates and other data. In the meantime, the transportation director tabulated the number of bus driver absences submitted via computer — by those living outside our area. By 5 a.m., it was clear that areas north of us, regardless of our own weather situation, were impacted such that bus drivers and other staff could not come to work. That made my decision “easy,” and we closed the schools for the day.

The chief criticism received that day was from parents who needed to make daycare arrangements for their children and thought that notification by 5:15 a.m. was too late. One parent said it was “brutal” that she received a wake-up phone call from the school district at 5:15 a.m. I agree that notification the night before is ideal, but cancelling school unnecessarily is an even greater daycare inconvenience for many.

My hat is off to our Communications Department. Based on the department’s preparatory work, our district has an incredible ability to inform thousands within seconds/minutes. We can instantly send TV/radio notifications, parent emails, Facebook/Twitter posts, and recorded voice messages to every household that took the time to submit its contact information. Whether a parent chose to find out through watching TV, reading email, listening to a phone call, examining Facebook or Twitter, reading our website, or listening to the radio, the information was available within seconds of 5:15 that morning. Although we inevitably hear from a few that “no one told them,” such problems are solved by just a little personal initiative (like turning the TV set on or going to our website).

Fortunately, the following week’s decision was easier. By 9:00 on the night before the predicted bad weather event, ALL of the schools in the Houston area, including Pearland, decided to close. Thus, those needing an earlier notification were pleased. Ironically, the weather turned out to be milder than predicted, and it would have been possible to hold school here! Thus, some criticized the decision as unnecessary, made too early (!), and the cause of unnecessary daycare inconveniences.

One other thing: A few wrote it was outrageous that our school district might put their child on a school bus or in their parent’s car when any bad weather was possible. I answer thus: Parents remain completely in charge of such decisions. Even if the schools are open, parents may elect to keep their kids at home. Some in our society seem to forget they have personal responsibility for such decisions. The argument that a child would be “horribly behind” if he missed a day of school is simply untrue. Though we do get after parents/children who are chronically and inexcusably absent, the schools are very understanding about rare absences — and allow make-ups for any assignments/material/tests missed.

In conclusion: In the absence of an accurate crystal ball or a working time machine, we must continue to make imperfect decisions on the weather — and endure the ramifications. I really appreciate the vast majority of people who understand these things.

Perhaps I’m happiest with this thought: Not a single child or staff member was hurt by the decisions made these two difficult days in January. That matters most.

5 Responses to “BAD WEATHER DECISIONS”


  1. 1 Kristen May 7, 2014 at 1:16 pm

    This PISD teacher enjoyed two rare snuggle days with my young son (his daycare also closed) and was happy not to have to get in the car and drive to work with unpredictable conditions.

    Good parenting sense should prevail and if a parent *thinks* school may close the next day, make emergency arrangements for the kids. If school is open, the worst that happens is you call and cancel those arrangements and everyone goes on their merry way. Not sure why some in the community find that so difficult to do.

  2. 2 Cassie Raftis-Parker February 22, 2014 at 9:15 pm

    Mr. Kelly, You make me proud to work for Pearland ISD!

  3. 4 Danette Wright-Windsor February 22, 2014 at 9:05 pm

    Kudos to you, Dr. Kelly! I am a Pearland transplant, originally from Kansas, but spent my college years (plus a few after) in Wisconsin. Needless to say, I know a few things about snow days. I would first like to commend PISD on the phone call that I received at 5:15 the first morning. Was it inconvenient to wake up to? Yes. Have I ever been given the courtesty of a phone call alerting me that school was canceled…NEVER. In fact, MOST snow days I have ever experienced were NOT decided until the day of. Which brings me to my next point – any parent that saw the news the night before, went on facebook, twitter, or has a telephone knew that other schools were closing, and it was a possibility that Pearland would also close. At that moment, parents should take responsibility for their own childcare needs so they have a plan in action IF the schools close. If not, they were still prepared. It is unfortunate that parents complained about that; it is a part of parenting and not the job of our educators. Common sense is not so common anymore. My only “complaint” was that school was canceled in the first place – but that is because I have trudged my son through feet of snow to get to school, so my opinion is biased. But really, Texas is not used to the kind of weather we received those days and I would rather have my children home, safe with me, than the alternative. Dr. Kelly, I would like to thank you for putting my PISD student, your faculty, and the residents of Pearland first. You hit the nail on the head – “Not a single child or staff member was hurt by the decisions made these two difficult days in January. That matters most.”

    Sincerely,
    Danette Wright-Windsor

  4. 5 Rachel Hinds February 21, 2014 at 5:34 pm

    I am always amazed at the “armchair quarterbacking” done by individuals after such an event. The correct answer is always easy after the fact. Although an earlier decision would have been convenient, it was not prudent in the first event. i commend Pearland ISD for making decisions intended to keep our children and the staff safe. As a native northerner, I can tell you NO ONE is safe on the roads in icy conditions.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s





%d bloggers like this: